Unit 8: Making a living - primary, secondary, tertiary industries and trade

(Alfred Hecht)

Teaching aim: Problem oriented overview on the principal economic sectors with special consideration of the primary industries, secondary industries (manufacturing), trade and service industries.

Keywords: Agriculture, forestry, fishery, mining, primary resources, energie, manufacturing, Auto-pact, High-Tech, trade, trading partners, retailing, services


In the mid-1990s, primary resources contributed just over 7% to Canada's gross domestic product, manufacturing and construction 24%, and the service industries 69%. This distribution reflects the importance of manufacturing and service industries in modern industrial economies, but an abundance of natural resources [1] has been extremely important in the development of Canada, and remains a vital foundation of the Canadian economy, especially its export sector. A closer look at its component is therefore justified (see Staple growth theory table).

Canada is energy rich. However, the different kinds of energy sources are unevenly distributed within the country, and hydroelectricity, coal, oil, and natural gas usually have to be shipped long distances from where they are produced to the main markets where they are needed. Each of these commodities is also exported, and in turn Canada imports energy when it is cheaper to use foreign supplies. Thus there is a great flow of energy both within Canada and in and out of the country.

Hydroelectricity [2] is available in all major regions of the country, although installations are few in the North because of freeze-up problems in winter and small markets, and non-existent in Prince Edward Island because of its low elevation. The first large generating facilities in Canada were built in Ontario at Niagara Falls, and there are other power plants downstream on the St. Lawrence River in both Ontario and Quebec, greatly expanded in the 1950s in connection with the building of the St. Lawrence Seaway. The Canadian Shield with its numerous lakes and rivers and considerable local relief provides tremendous potential for generating hydroelectricity, and there are installations in many places from Labrador through to Saskatchewan and the Northwest Territories. Quebec has huge installations, some of which have become notorious because large tracts of land east of James Bay used by Native peoples were flooded when reservoirs were created. In Labrador, power is produced mainly for export to the United States. To transmit the electricity through Quebec to the United States, the electric power is sold to Hydro-Quebec, which sells the energy to the U.S. In Quebec much cheap electric power is used to refine aluminum from bauxite. Ontario electric power needs are so great that it has had to turn to nuclear reactors as well as using hydroelectricity, but Manitoba has a large surplus of hydro power it produces in the Shield that is also exported to the United States. British Columbia has great hydroelectric installations in river valleys in the Cordillera, and exports power to the United States under long term agreements. There is potential to produce more hydro electricity in Canada, but this would once again involve flooding large areas that are the homelands of Native peoples. However, today the total negative impacts are thought to be far greater then the positive ones and hence no new major stations are being planned.

Coal [3] has long been mined on the Atlantic coast in Nova Scotia, where it remains the foundation of a small iron and steel industry. Coal was also mined on the Pacific coast in Vancouver Island, but those mines are now closed. Canada's largest coal mines today are in the Rocky Mountains and adjacent foothills, and in the Great Plains. Together these two areas produce over 95% of Canada's coal. Alberta is the leading province, followed by British Columbia and Saskatchewan. The thermal coal produced is mainly used within Canada, and the metallurgical coal is exported, mainly to Japan. Canada's industrial heart in Ontario and Quebec does not have coal, and the coal needed for the iron and steel industry of Ontario is imported from the United States. In Nova Scotia, Ontario, Saskatchewan and Alberta coal is also used to produce thermal electricity.

Petroleum [4] was first produced in southern Ontario in the nineteenth century, and then in the early twentieth century in Alberta, but only in small quantities. Until 1947, Canada remained largely dependent upon imports for its petroleum needs, but in that year a large oil field was discovered south of Edmonton, Alberta, which transformed the industry. Presently, Alberta is by far the largest oil producing province, followed by Saskatchewan, and both provinces, and also British Columbia, have huge quantities of natural gas [5]. Pipelines carry oil and gas to the large markets in Ontario and Quebec, and to the United States. Large oil reserves have been proven in the Arctic, but they are not being exploited at present because alternative sources that are cheaper to develop are available. On the Atlantic Ocean continental shelf, oil is produced off Nova Scotia, and the huge Hibernia oil field [6], well out in the Atlantic, 310 km from St. John's, Newfoundland, started production in 1998. In northern Alberta, much oil is produced from the oil sands [7] located along the Athabasca River at Fort McMurray. The oil sands comprise some of the largest oil reserves in the world.

Interpretations of Canadian economic development emphasize the importance of export primary commodities such as fish, furs, farm products and minerals, first mainly to markets in Europe and then to the United States. These goods were the early driving forces behind the country's growth, and are still significant in the Canadian economy. The fisheries [8] are most significant on the Atlantic and Pacific coastal shelves, but are also carried out in numerous freshwater lakes in interior Canada. Since 1992, the cod fishery has been closed on the Atlantic continental shelf, destroyed by over-fishing, and the fish stock is being monitored closely for indications that it may be recovering. In the meantime the closure has devastated many communities, particularly in Newfoundland. Right across Canada the forest industry [9] is of great importance. British Columbia, with its great temperate rainforest is the leading producer, consistently producing about one half of CanadaÕs forest product, and the industry has also been long important in Quebec, Ontario, and New Brunswick. More recently, forestry [10] has attained greater significance in Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba, where the forests of the central and northern sections of those provinces are exploited. Canadian forest products produced for export include pulp and paper.

When one thinks of Canadian agriculture one often thinks of the wheat fields [11] of the prairies, and particularly Saskatchewan. When the price of grains is high and yields are good, Saskatchewan with its huge acreages in grain crops can be the leading agricultural province by value of farms products produced. Wheat, other small grains, and canola [12] are important crops on the prairies. Southern Ontario, with its diversified and relatively intensive agriculture, growing cash crops such as corn and soybeans, with mixed farms producing dairy products and beef cattle, and with vegetable, grape, and fruit growing in favoured areas, often is the leading province. Recently, however, Alberta has taken the lead ahead of Ontario and Saskatchewan as its cities grow, providing an increasing market for dairy products, and with its large areas in cattle ranches and grain fields. Manitoba grows grain, and has mixed farms, and British Columbia with a large urban market produces dairy products, and in the interior, fruit growing under irrigation and ranching are significant. Quebec leads the country in dairy products, and diversified agriculture is significant in the Maritimes. Prince Edward Island and New Brunswick are specialty producers of potatoes, and fruit and vegetable growing is significant in Nova Scotia. The diversity of agriculture outputs [13] accross the nation is quite great. Canada as a whole is a great exporter of foodstuffs, especially wheat, canola, and cattle, and has a trade surplus in agricultural commodities, but it still imports many food products because of the need for tropical and sub-tropical fruit, such as bananas and oranges, and for vegetables during the winter season.

Alberta is consistently the leading mineral producing province, because of its high value oil and natural gas production. Provinces with extensive sections of the igneous and metamorhic rocks of the Shield potentially possess important commercially viable metallic mineral deposits of many kinds. Ontario produces gold, silver, copper, zinc, and nickel; Quebec, iron ore, gold, and base metals; Manitoba, nickel, copper and base metals; and Labrador, iron ore. In 1993, an extremely rich nickel deposit right on the Atlantic coast was discovered in Labrador and is being developed. Saskatchewan has the richest uranium deposits [14] in the world, located in the Shield, and is the worldÕs leading producer, and in the sedimentary strata of the southern interior plains in Saskatchewan are the world's leading potash deposits, used in making fertilizer. A wide variety of minerals are produced in British Columbia, including gold, copper, lead and zinc. Mining in British Columbia began with a well known gold rush in 1858 to the placer gold fields of the interior plateaus. However, what turned out to be the best known mineral find in Canadian history was the discovery of placer gold deposits in 1896 in the Yukon of today, culminating in the world famous Klondike gold rush [15] of 1898. Today, mining is much more important in the Northwest Territories than in Yukon. Yellowknife has been an important gold mining centre since the 1930s, and there is excitement about the opening in the next few years of Canada's first diamond mine [16], 290 km north of Yellowknife. This is north of the tree line in a region of permafrost where great care has to be taken in protecting the landscape and the caribou herds. Just north of Resolute, in the Northwest Territories is the farthest north mine in the world, producing lead and zinc since 1981 .

As can be seen from the above Canada has and still is using many resources to foster its development. In fact a theory of growth has been proposed to capture this phenomenon. It is called the staple growth theory. But with time the importance of resources in Canada's development has declined and with it the importance of the theory to present development efforts in Canada.

Secondary industries - Manufacturing

Since the late nineteenth century, Canada's centre of manufacturing has been concentrated in two provinces, Ontario and Quebec. Consistently, year after year, Ontario contributes about 50% of the Canadian total of manufactured goods produced, measured by value, and Quebec 25%. The largest share of Canada's iron and steel production is in Ontario, with coal coming from the United States, and iron ore from various places, including northern Quebec and Labrador. The year after Henry Ford [17] built his first automobile factory in Detroit, Michigan, in 1904, Ford established a branch plant across the Detroit River in what is now Windsor, Ontario. Since then the automobile assembly and automotive parts industry has remained the engine behind the Ontario economy, heavily influenced by the big United States automobile companies, Ford, General Motors, and Chrysler as well as all the major Japanese carmakers. There is no direct Canadian-owned automobile industry, although there are major Canadian-owned auto parts manufacturers. In 1965, a tariff agreement, commonly called the Auto Pact [18], was signed between Canada and the United States, facilitating the exchange of parts and assembled automobiles across the international border. The agreement ensured that the U.S. owned auto companies would manufacture in Canada automotive products that would as a minimum be equivalent in value to their products sold in Canada. This agreement has proved to be of great benefit to Canada, particularly Ontario where the automobile industry is almost entirely concentrated. Here Canada assembles twice as many cars as it buys. The Canadian aerospace industry is centred in Montreal, and that city is also the main location of Canadian garment manufacturing. Electronic high technology enterprises are concentrated in Ottawa, in close proximity to the National Research Council laboratories, and in the region near Toronto, where a number of important universities invloved in technological research are located.

Trade

Europe used to be the great market for the resource-based goods produced in Canada. be it food commodities such as fish or grain, or wood products. Europe is still a highly significant market, taking 7% of Canadian exports, but Canada's most important trading partners [19] at present are the United States and Japan. In 1995, 79% of Canada's exports went to the United State. In part this is so high because many raw materials are sent to the U.S., particularly lumber, pulp and paper, and minerals. Of even greater significance, however, is the flow of automotive products, part of the trade exchanges stemming from the Auto Pact. In turn, Canada imports more goods from the U.S. than from any other country, 67% of its total imports. Canada has a large trade surplus with the U.S., but in the trade exchange with many other countries Canada imports more than it exports. Apart from the United States, important trading partners are Japan, United Kingdom, Germany, France, and Italy, and with each of these countries Canada has a trade deficit. The general pattern of trade with Germany is typical. Canada tends to send raw materials, and some machinery and equipment to Germany, and gets back manufactured goods. In 1995, Canada sent goods valued at $3,150.3 million to Germany, and received goods worth $4,801 million. In its total trade balance Canada has a substantial surplus of exports over imports largely because of its advantageous trade relationship with the United States. The North American Free Trade Agreement between Canada, US, and Mexico may change this over time. With respect to kinds of commodities [20] traded, overall Canada has a trade surplus in agricultural, fishing, energy, forestry, industrial, and automotive products, but a deficit in machinery and equipment products, and consumer goods.

Services industries

The workers employed in the primary and secondary enterprises referred to above comprised about 26% of Canada's labour force of 14,832,000 persons in 1994. As in other industrialized parts of the world an increasing proportion of the working population [21] is in the service sector. In 1994, service workers comprised more than 74% of the total work force, and, of course, the majority of these persons worked in urban centres. There are hundreds of service occupations ranging from bus drivers, medical doctors, and service station attendants to store clerks, university administrators,plumbers, and lawyers, working in thousands of stores, service shops, schools, hospitals, city halls, and office buildings located in villages, towns, and cities scattered across the country .

A characteristic of Canada is that numerous commercial companies operate in all parts of the country, with their headquarters usually located in one of the major cities, and their subsidiaries in urban centres large and small across the land. Banks are a good example. Canada has only five major banks, all with their operating head offices in Montreal or Toronto, but each has a very extensive branch banking system with branch banks in towns and cities in every part of the country, involving thousands of employees. Similarly, there are national or regional chains of department, hardware, grocery, and drug stores, automobile dealerships and service stations, hotels, motels, and fast-food franchises and coffee houses, each with its distinctive building styles or advertising signs, distributed either within a major section of Canada or across the entire country. As a result the individuality of many commercial districts in towns and cities is almost obliterated by the overwhelming architectural conformity introduced by these service establishments owned either by Canadian or international corporations.

Questions for further consideration:

  • Why is the employment in the primary sector so low even though Canada is known for its plentiful resources?
  • What role has the Canada-Us AutoPact played in creating NAFTA?
  • Which are the new staples of Canada and how important are they to Canada now?
Interactive Quiz

[1] http://www.nrcan-rncan.gc.ca/inter/index_e.html
[2] http://www.canhydropower.org/hydro_e/p_hyd_b.htm
[3] http://www.coal.ca
[4] http://www.pcf.ab.ca/silos/ET-CanEn01.asp
[5] http://www2.nrcan.gc.ca/es/ener2000/online/html/chap3b_e.cfm
[6] http://www.gov.nf.ca/mines&en/maps/offshore/SDOGB.pdf
[7] http://www.nrcan-rncan.gc.ca:80/media/newsreleases/1996/199609a_e.htm
[8] http://www.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/communic/statistics/commercial/landings/index_e.htm
[9] http://www.portes.ouvertes.cppa.ca
[10] http://www.forest.ca
[11] http://www.newholland.com/na/news/nhn/Sept01/V47No6_3.htm
[12] http://www.ag.usask.ca/exhibits/walkway/story/canola.html
[13] http://www.cfa-fca.ca/english/agriculture_in_canada/commodities.html
[14] http://www.uic.com.au/nip03.htm
[15] http://www.nps.gov/klgo/
[16] http://www.ainc-inac.gc.ca/nr/ecd/ssd/otm11_e.html
[17] http://www.motorsportshalloffame.com/halloffame/1993/Henry_Ford_main.htm
[18] http://archives.cbc.ca/IDD-1-73-326/politics_economy/auto_pact/
[19] http://www.statcan.ca/english/Pgdb/gblec02a.htm
[20] http://www.statcan.ca/english/Pgdb/gblec04.htm
[21] http://www.statcan.ca/english/Pgdb/labor21a.htm


TOP CONTENT VGT HOME